My Giveaway + Announcements

*My first foray into an Author Interview with Andrew Xia Fukuda is up! (Should I do more?)
*My first manga review for Natsume Yuujinchou V.1 - please let me know what you think

Tuesday, November 10, 2009

Review: Book of a Thousand Days by Shannon Hale

...my schedule is fairly much going down the drain. But hey, this is my first normal review, so yay?! =D




Title: Book of a Thousand Days
Author(s): Shannon Hale
Genre: YA Fantasy Fairy Tale Retelling
Page Count: 306
Publisher: Bloomsbury

Summary: When Lady Saren refuses to marry a man she fears, she and her maid, Dashti, are locked in a tower with just a tiny flap open to the outside world. As food runs low and the weather changes from broiling hot to unbearably cold, it is all Dashti can do to make them comfortable in their dark prison.
Not long after their confinement begins, Saren's suitors arrive-one welcom, the other less so-and she orders Dashti to speak to them. Impersonating Lady Saren is a crime punishable by death, but Dashti will have to play the role many times if she is to save them both from the tower and the dangers outisde. As she takes control of their desperate situation, Dashti begins to understand her own astonishing talents and believe that even a low-born maid can find true love.

The Review: First off, this is the first time I ever came across a YA fairy tale novel retelling that wasn't set in Europe. Can I say LOVE AT FIRST SIGHT?! And the world was very distinctly Mongolian, from the food they ate to the clothes they wore and just, everything. . ♥ I thought Hale did a very through research, personally. Also helping with the setting is an inclusion of the map in the Bloomsbury USA version, and all the little illustrations inserted all throughout the novel. This novel has a very strong sense of place, a well-grounded setting, and I really appreciate this aspect.

I really enjoyed the diary format of the novel. We get a very strong closed 1st person perspective this way and our narrator Dashti is very sweet and strong-willed and fun to read from. The illustrations drawn in are very effective and flow well with the diary format. In short, no complaints, and very enjoyable writing that flows well and is easy to read.

If I must be critical about this book, it’d be the whole Villainous Evil Characters of Irredeemable Evil. Khasar was evil and even animalistic about his villainy. (Yes, they went there.) Vachir the love rival had no redeeming qualities. Also problematic was how the whole classicism thing was dealt with. I don’t think Hale subverted the princess and the maid dynamic as much as she could have. Saren still, for the most part, held too much commanding power all the way to the end over Dashti for me to really think of their relationship as equals. SPOILERS FOR ENDING (thanks to ninefly for helping me with spoiler tag: [I thought they didn’t challenge the class issue enough with Dashti and Tegus either and the ending really didn’t help matters. Don’t get me wrong, I loved the ending and was really happy that Dashti and Tegus ended up together at the end but on retrospect it was still problematic. I mean, the reason why Dashti was able to be Tegus’ bride was by becoming gentry herself. In other words, she must change her status as mucker, a very essential part of her identity, in order to marry him. That does not send out a particularly positive message nor subvert classicism problems, so. =/]

The romance between our heroine and the requisite prince is adorable and sweet as required out of the fairytale. I will not lie, while reading the book, towards the end I was like “I do not CARE what unrealistic deus ex machina move they pull, TEGUS AND DASHTI MUST END UP TOGETHER AND GET MARRIED, DAMNIT.” I don’t think it’s particularly spoilery on my part to admit that this fairy tale retelling gave us our Happily Ever After in spades.

Anyhow, this is a lush, beautiful fairy tale retelling set in a fantastical Ancient Mongolian universe that will deliver on all the troupes that every fairy tale must have yet exploring the vast and fascinating world and the characters in ways only the length of a novel can allow. Highly recommended for those who love their fairy tales that aren't whitewashed

Rating: 3.5/5
Enjoyment 90%

Title and Cover Discussion: I’m not sure how to feel about the title. I mean, on one hand it’s rather eye-catching, but on the other if we calculate the days it wasn’t exactly a thousand days. (It’s 1110 if we want to be exact.) But hey, in history we often aren’t exact about numbers either, so I don’t begrudge that. (The Hundred Year War wasn’t for a hundred years, the 300 spartans wasn’t exactly 300, etc etc) Also, the cover I received was the Bloomsbury USA paperback one so I got a face on my cover! Which made me really happy, since this may be the only YA fairy tale retelling that had a heroine so blatantly Asian on the cover. So much better than the hardcover, which I noticed it simply showed her hands holding a book. x.x I love the font for the title too and thought it looks really pretty with the cover et all. =D

Title: B
Cover: A++++ (for the paperback. The hardcover version can bite me)

6 comments:

ninefly said...

gwah, the spoiler html thing didn't work like I'd planned, I'll send you another version when I figure it out...it's fairly illegible though? 8D

as for the book...you're not really helping me like it D: for some reason I get the impression that Saren is unlikeable, and the evil/good dichotomy really irks me too
though...it IS mongolian...and it has PICTURES ♥
maybe I'll leech it off you later 8X

Ah Yuan // wingstodust said...

LULZ. Well, your enjoyment of the novel is basically if you are a sucker for fairy tales (like me) and its troupes don't annoy you. I actually think Saren is okay, though weak-willed and the whole crazy thing irked me a lot (and I STILL think Hale could have worked that in some more), but then I tend to like my selfish characters that everyone hates, so you shouldn't listen to me. ^^;;; I was basically like, MONGOLIAN FAIRY TALE. AND PICTURES. AND HAPPILY EVER AFTERS AND THE OTP IS ADORABLE. So if you're up for fluff and avoid thinking about the Various Problematic Issues Portrayed in this novel, it's a really fun read, honest. Dashti is the cutest and so sweet. <3

MissAttitude said...

I really want to read this book because there are so few re-tellings of fairytales with poc! and I'm curious to see if I agree about the issues of class. Very well-written review, you really broke down why you liked the book and why you didn't.
I gave up on keeping a schedule for blogging within a month of starting :D

Ah Yuan // wingstodust said...

*blushes* Thanks! I'm glad the review worked and you know, didn't sound like a ramblings of a madwoman... ^^;; Do read it, I'm curious to hear about what you think about the book!! =D
lol, at least you lasted within a month. I faltered in less than a week. *dies*

Misty said...

I loved Dashti and I LOVED Tegus. I pretty much agreed with everything you said, honestly. And I loved the setting. Hale is very good at atmosphere and scene setting.

Laura C. said...

Loved this book!